Most everyone has heard of the famous villain that goes by the name, ‘Joker.’ What we have never really been told in any film is how the Joker came to be. What caused his downfall? Why was he so obsessed with the Wayne family? Did society create him or was the darkness inside him his whole life? Todd Phillips created such a haunting and visually stunning masterpiece that answers all of the above questions. While the overtone of the film is dark and chaotic, the main theme throughout is one of sadness and heartache.
We meet Arthur Fleck, a clown and wannabe comedian who seems to have drawn the short end of the stick for most of his life. He lives with his elderly mother and suffers from a mental disorder that causes him to laugh uncontrollably during unexpected and inappropriate times. Society shuns him and fails to understand what he is going through. Times are tough in Gotham City and Arthur’s condition doesn’t help. At first, Arthur seems like a rather gentle soul who clearly doesn’t understand social cues or basic human interaction. For some reason his weirdness attracts bullies and we witness him beaten up twice for it. It’s at this moment and through a series of misfortunes that we begin to see the downfall of Arthur Fleck and the rise of Joker.
I will admit there are times where this film is very hard to watch. I wanted to look away but every second kept drawing me closer and closer to the storyline. Joaquin Phoenix’s portrayal of the character is truly mesmerizing and haunting. The physicality of his performance is shocking to look yet adds to the character in a way that no makeup or costume department could do. He contorts his arms and face in a way that captures a man who looks like he is uncomfortable in his own skin. You don’t want to, but Phoenix’s performance makes you feel an emotional attachment to Arthur and sympathy for the pain he is going through.
There was a moment closer to the beginning of the film when Arthur is writing down jokes in his journal. The last thing he writes on the page is, “The worst part of having a mental illness is people expect you to behave as if you don’t.” That line has been engraved in my brain ever since I watched the movie and let me tell you, it disturbs me. The truth behind that one line is tragic and so real that it’s scary.
What is so intriguing about this film is the fact that it brings the subject of mental illness to light. One of the most powerful messages by the end was how society failed Arthur. Society failed him by taking away the government funding he needed. Society failed him by constantly making fun of his disorder. Society failed him by not attempting to understand his condition. In a way, society made him into the villain; Gotham City created the Joker. Without knowing, Arthur made himself into the symbol of the lower class. Because of the crimes he committed the lower class thought they too could commit crimes and riot all over the city. This is one of the leading causes of Gotham City becoming so dark and sinister. The rise of Joker meant the downfall of Gotham City.
While some people argue about the message of the film and what it is trying to portray; it is really is up to the audience to decide. Joaquin Phoenix explained it as, “This movie requires a certain amount of participation from the audience…It’s up to you how you want to interpret it and experience it. It’s less you being kind of presented with the facts than you being presented with the possibilities.” There is no right or wrong way to interpret the film. Is the storyline real or is the entire thing going on in Arthur Fleck’s head? I don’t have the answer to that question, and Todd Phillips and Joaquin Phoenix are staying quiet on that subject.
Joker was nominated for 11 Academy Awards and managed to walk away with two. Hildur Guðnadóttir won for Best Achievement in Music Written for Motion Pictures and let me tell you that win is well deserved. Her interpretation of the mood and emotions of each scene is impeccable. She brings humanity to the chaos and makes you feel empathetic for Arthur. Through her music we actually feel closer to the emotional depth of Fleck’s character. The second win went to Joaquin Phoenix for Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role. His haunting and disturbing portrayal of Arthur Fleck turned Joker was compelling, raw, and emotional. The sheer amount of weight he lost for the role is enough reason for him to win in my opinion. Should Joker have won more than just two Academy Awards? For me the answer is yes…but obviously it’s not up to me.
Image credit: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/oct/09/week-in-geek-joaquin-phoenix-joker-must-be-isolated-from-batman-dc-comics